May 2005
The Role of Faith in the Patient-Physician Relationship
1. In the case of a fetus with a severe genetic condition like trisomy 13, which of the following options would be acceptable to both an observant Catholic patient and a non-religious doctor?
| |
A. |
Medical abortion to spare the child a short lifetime filled with suffering. |
| |
B. |
Early induction of labor for therapeutic reasons that would more than likely cause the infant's death, although that would not be the main goal of the procedure. |
| |
C. |
Normal course for the pregnancy that allows "nature to take it's course" without extraordinary care. |
| |
D. |
Monitoring the pregnancy, planning for a live birth, and then providing all the care necessary for the child to have the most comfortable life. |
| |
E. |
C and D. |
2. An Orthodox Jewish physician is forbidden by Jewish law to:
| |
A. |
Force treatment on a patient against his or her will. |
| |
B. |
Perform an act that hastens a patient's death. |
| |
C. |
Withdraw nutrition, hydration, or oxygen from a terminally ill patient. |
| |
D. |
All of the above. |
| |
E. |
A and B. |
3. When a physician's religious beliefs dictate that he or she not provide a standard medical treatment that a patient is requesting, the physician should:
| |
A. |
Attempt to persuade the patient to accept the physician's point of view. |
| |
B. |
Tell the patient that this request is unacceptable and suggest that he or she find another doctor to provide the treatment. |
| |
C. |
Explain why the physician cannot provide the treatment and work with the patient to find an alternative that is acceptable to both. |
| |
D. |
Provide the requested treatment if it conforms with medical standard of care. |
4. When a patient attempts to evangelize his or her psychiatrist, it is appropriate for the psychiatrist to:
| |
A. |
Tell the patient that discussion of his or her religious beliefs has no place in the therapeutic encounter. |
| |
B. |
Ask to learn more about how the patient's religious beliefs guide his or her daily actions and behavior. |
| |
C. |
Use the therapeutic encounter as a means for discovering whether the patient's religion is one the psychiatrist might want to adopt. |
| |
D. |
Make sure the patient understands the clear distinction between his or her beliefs and his or her psychiatric illness. |
5. The clinical pearl outlines several goals of a patient spiritual assessment. Which of the following is not one of those goals?
| |
A. |
Give the physician a way to evaluate the merits of the patient's religion. |
| |
B. |
Provide a safe, therapeutic setting for patients to discuss their spiritual preferences as they relate to medical care. |
| |
C. |
Use an approach that will be acceptable and helpful for any patient regardless of religious or cultural background. |
| |
D. |
Keep patient needs as the primary focus. |
| |
E. |
A and D. |
6. A pregnant woman refuses, on religious grounds, treatment needed for her survival and that of her fetus. According to Illinois case law:
| |
A. |
Those who wish to override her refusal are encouraged to seek a court order do so. |
| |
B. |
The state's interest in the life of the woman's fetus overrides her right to refuse the treatment. |
| |
C. |
The woman's right to refuse treatment overrides the state's interest in the life of her fetus. |
| |
D. |
The physician and hospital can impose the treatment on the woman for the benefit of the fetus as long as the treatment is not considered "invasive." |
| |
E. |
She must demonstrate proof of her membership in the faith tradition that forbids the treatment. |
7. One of the strengths of the literature on the effects of spirituality on health is a uniform definition of "spirituality" throughout the studies.
8. In the play Equus, the psychiatrist is concerned that medicine may have a negative effect on his patient Alan because:
| |
A. |
It could make Alan less violent towards the horses. |
| |
B. |
It may alter the passion and purpose in Alan's life, ultimately leaving a void in his personality. |
| |
C. |
Treatment might strain the already fragile relationship between Alan and his parents. |
| |
D. |
Medical intervention could force Alan to recall painful memories. |
9. If a community health clinic, such as the Lawndale Christian Health Center in Chicago, wishes to be eligible for federal funding, it must not offer any faith-based services.
10. According the Interfaith Health Program, physicians' first steps into the area of faith-health interaction should:
| |
A. |
Recognize that faith is more like health than like illness. |
| |
B. |
Seek from patients what they think is the cause of their life, their thriving, and vitality. |
| |
C. |
Seek to determine in what ways religious-social networks are assets for health. |
| |
D. |
All of the above. |
| |
E. |
A and C. |
The viewpoints expressed on this site are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the AMA.
© 2005 American Medical Association. All Rights Reserved.